Case File 1001: Elizabeth Grave

 

Case File Details
Case Number: 2007-1001 Date: Start Time: End Time:
Investigators: Bobby, Sara, Dave  ,Chris
Equipment Log: Chillicothe Library,
Known Accounts:
 
In this case we are not only investigating, we are also doing extensive research.  This case is one we all agreed that we needed bust.  Over the past few years the  Elizabeth myth has gotten out of control.  The grave yard is a wreck, and desecrated in morbid ways.  So far our results are leading us to our expected result. That this story is nothing but an urban legend.  We hope to bust this legend so that the people of the Mount Union-Pleasant Valley Cemetery can rest in peace. 
 
Myths:
Here are a few myth we have dug up on Elizabeth
*Elizabeth was hanged from a tree in the back of the grave yard.  Note that there is a tree in the corner of the graveyard that people claim to have seen this apparition.
 
*Elizabeth was beheaded by townspeople because she inherited her husbands land after he past.
 
*Someone took Elizabeth's baby, and she soon hung her self.
 
*Elizabeth was a witch.
 
*Elizabeth had her baby taken away from her and she hanged herself out of depression.

 

 

Investigation/ Research Notes:
 
These are the  Elizabeth's that are buried in the graveyard.  So far none of these Elizabeth's died according to any of the myths.  As soon as we confirm a death it will be posted.

Abernathy, Elizabeth 12/30/1786 to 12/14/1842 aged 55 years  ( Myth Busted )

 
Augustus, Elizabeth born 8/21/1836 to (no date of death)
 
Beard, Elizabeth 6/17/1831 to 5/28/1852 aged 21 years
 
Bostwick, Eliza 1/14/1813 to 11/22/1864 aged 51 years
 
Clark, Elizabeth 1782 to 8/14/1858 aged 76 years
 
Eagleson, Elizabeth 1822 to 7/4/1884 aged 62 years
 
Henness, Elizabeth 1792 to 10/4/1869 aged 77 years
 
Henness, Elizabeth 3/16/1816 to 11/19/1838 aged 22 years
 
Henness, Elizabeth 1/12/1834 to 5/28/1850 aged 16 years ( Myth Busted)
 
Hodsden, Lizzie 11/13/1866 to 3/2/1895 aged 31 years
 
Ogden, Elizabeth died 6/13/1850
 
Robinson, Elizabeth died 4/1824
 
Stitt, Elizabeth 5/3/1804 to 4/5/1827 aged 22 years

So far here are two Elizabeth's that we found. Both died a usual death (sickness or natural).  Note:  The 16 year old that died from illness is the Elizabeth that most people claim the "witch legend" is based upon. 
Personal Experiences:
 
We will be heading to the site area to do a physical investigation as soon as we gain permission.